Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks

We’ve ordered from Antonella’s more frequently these past few weeks and cannot find a better margarita pizza anywhere! Perfect mix of fluffy crust with crunchy bottom, and the flavor is on point.
We also ordered wings, mozzarella sticks, and several pasta dishes.
Everything was really tasty! My family all agrees that the pizza and wings are our preference for game nights.
We primarily order to go, and have not had any issues with our take out orders. Additionally, Marley and Carlos at this location provided excellent customer service and were extremely welcoming.
Highly recommend!

Well, I work in downtown Winter Park and really wanted a Calzone today.
I already tried one from another Pizza place nearby, but it was not good.
And definitely worth the price. So I gave these guys a chance.
And you know what? Not bad at all! Actually, it was pretty good! Today, I tried the Antonella's Calzone and although the price might be a bit high, it is definitely worth it. The thing was massive, and I couldn't eat the entire thing.
I just wish it had a bit more Italian sausage, which I will probably request as an extra add-on the next time I place an order. I love that they sell pizza by the slice.
It is also a great option if you want to try different toppings, are on a budget, etc. All in all....
yes, I would recommend this place.
And before I forget, the staff at the restaurant was super nice and accommodating. Next time, I will definitely dine in, so I can try their pizza fresh out of the oven.
I'm pretty sure it's going to be really good.
So there will definitely be updates to this post.

Ordered a pepperoni pizza, thin, well done and light on the sauce to go.
Showed up to pick it up and it wasn’t ready so my girlfriend and I sat down and waited for it.
We ordered two sodas while we waited but there were only two to choose from.
All the other sodas were not available.
Our drinks were getting poured from 2 Liter bottles and to make matters even worse, they were out of drink lids. When the pizza was ready, well, you take a look at the photo and tell me if this looks thin and well done?? The dough was very dry as well.
Even the spacing of the pepperoni’s was horrendous.
Whoever made this pie certainly didn’t make it with love.
Almost 30 bucks later and I would’ve been happier with Hungry Howies.
I really hate to say that but it is what it is.
Totally disappointed and embarrassed for the owner.
We’ve been here many times before and this certainly wasn’t the Antonella’s pizza that we’re used to.
When we left the only thing that we could come up with is that the original owners sold the place.
It was that disappointing.