4.7 stars based on 700 ratingsToday's hours: 12-7 pmAdd a review
$$ Pizza restaurant, Restaurant
About
Tortugas Pizza is a beloved spot in Birmingham known for its Chicago-style pies that have locals raving. You’ll find it at 1304 2nd Ave S, where fast service meets a cozy, trendy atmosphere perfect for families, students, or anyone craving comfort food. With an impressive selection of vegetarian options, small plates, and a well-stocked bar, there’s something for everyone. Although parking can be a challenge, many agree that the delicious, homemade deep-dish pizza makes every step worth it!
Tortugas Pizza is a gem on 2nd Ave S! 🍕 I visited on a rainy day and was pleasantly surprised by the cozy atmosphere and friendly service. I ordered the Chicago-style deep dish Carne Special with black olives and jalapenos, and it reminded me of home - rich, cheesy, and perfectly baked.
About a 45-minute wait, but worth every minute! My only critique is that the crust was a bit tough.
If you're in Birmingham, don't miss out! Just be prepared for tricky parking... but trust me, it's worth it! 🤤
