Brooklyn Pizza

Name: Brooklyn Pizza
Address: 2035 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, Florida, 32304, US
Telephone: (850) 224-5454
Price range: $
Rating: 4.00

Pizza restaurant, Chicken wings restaurant, Restaurant

Located on W Pensacola St in Tallahassee, Brooklyn Pizza charms diners with its inviting ambiance and delectable New York-style pies. Loved for its crispy crust and delightful topping combinations, don’t miss the chance to try their wings—especially the Hot Garlic Parm! With a very reasonable price tag and sweet, attentive staff, it’s a great spot for a laid-back meal. Though some wish for a creamier mozzarella, many guests celebrate its cozy vibe and excellent service. It’s definitely worth a visit!

Contact Info

Location: 2035 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304
Phone: (850) 224-5454
Price range: $

Opening hours

Monday: 11 am-11 pm
Tuesday: 11 am-11 pm
Wednesday: 11 am-11 pm
Thursday: 11 am-11 pm
Friday: 11 am-11 pm
Saturday: 11 am-11 pm
Sunday: 11 am-11 pm

Other Business Hours

Delivery

Monday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Tuesday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Wednesday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Thursday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Friday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Saturday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Sunday: 10:30 am-11 pm

Takeout

Monday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Tuesday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Wednesday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Thursday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Friday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Saturday: 10:30 am-11 pm
Sunday: 10:30 am-11 pm

Services

Food & drink

Pizza

cheese pizza

Stromboli

Chicken Wings

By owner

Street View

Menus and Prices

Menu 1

Menu 2

Menu 3

Menu 4

Menu 5

Add Your Review

Reviews

Pizza was good while hot out of the oven.
Decent crust.
However, they need to get a higher quality mozzarella because their current does not reheat well. Employees are very sweet and accommodating.
Good experience as far as customer service.
Please change your mozzarella and you will have a customer for life.

Awesome place! Always knew it was in town but never considered it.
Finally tried it out a few weeks ago and it's great! I've been back 5 times! They even have dine-in options. The New York style pizza, of course, is wonderful.
It's a must to get Pesto sauce on whatever toppings! Try it! But it's the wings that hooked me! That Hot Garlic Parm hits EVERY time! Would recommend this place to anyone.

I’m from Ny born and raised and I always liked my pizza extra cheesy and saucy I ordered extra on both! However I did not receive! This is what I got for 63$ plus boneless wings I am extremely disappointed I’ll stick to momos I’ll will be doing a TikTok review soon! Update!!! They did the pizzas over the cook was very kind when he brought it out to me said he has been there since 2004! But this is the result and I am pleased might I add they did the pizzas over with no problems! I appreciate that!