Tony's Pier shines as a beloved seafood spot on City Island, renowned for its casual and cozy atmosphere. Offering a range of dishes, from fried lobster tails to shrimp baskets, patrons rave about the generous portions and quick service—perfect for a satisfying lunch or dinner. While the flavors can sometimes be understated, the drinks, including their popular piña colada, make for a delightful pairing. With accommodating amenities and plenty of parking, it’s a great choice for groups and families alike.
Tony's Pier is a charming seafood gem on City Island! 🌊
I recently stopped by for dinner, and the fried lobster tails were absolutely incredible! Juicy, crispy, and paired perfectly with their delightful cocktails. The atmosphere was cozy, and the service was quick and friendly.
While I found the calamari a bit greasy, the overall experience was fantastic - especially the piña colada! 🍹
It's cash-only, but there's an ATM on-site, making it convenient. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in the Bronx craving seafood. Can’t wait to return!
