Shelby Street Tavern

Name: Shelby Street Tavern
Address: 2849 Shelby St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46203, US
Telephone: (317) 875-1932
Price range: $
Rating: 4.70

Bar, Grill

Location: 2849 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203, United States
Phone: (317) 875-1932
Price: $

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed
Monday: 3 pm-1 am
Tuesday: 3 pm-1 am
Wednesday: 3 pm-1 am
Thursday: 3 pm-1 am
Friday: 3 pm-2 am
Saturday: 3 pm-2 am

Kitchen

Sunday: Closed
Monday: 4-10 pm
Tuesday: 4-10 pm
Wednesday: 4-10 pm
Thursday: 4-10 pm
Friday: 4-10 pm
Saturday: 4-10 pm

Food & drink

Vibe

By owner

Street View

Menus and Prices

Add Your Review

Reviews

Don't let the exterior fool you! This place is really nice and welcoming.
The inside has been updated and looks great! It's clean, modern, and relaxed.
The first floor is fairly small, so on busy nights I could see it getting a little cramped, but don't let that dissuade you! Even the bathrooms were very clean and well maintained. Their food menu is small, but the chicken, bacon, and ranch pizza was really good.
The BBQ sauce on top was a bit weird though.
They had a good selection of drinks, however I think the kegerator was on the fritz because the beer I got was not cold, but still tasted fine. The bartender was incredibly friendly, and the owners came in at one point and seemed genuinely interested in getting customer feedback and asked about what sort of events would folks be interested in. Overall, I had a great experience and would definitely recommend checking this place out if you're in the area.

I have to give Buzz and Mel 5 stars.
The chicken dinner was so freaking delicious, the servings are for us big eaters.
The fried chicken livers are also fire.
I like their establishment, it's friendly and inviting.
Only thing I'd like to see is, they get Jim Beam Redstag in.
They have every other flavor but, Redstag.
So glad I stopped in to try your food, certainly impressed and not at all disappointed.
I look forward to the next time, you have won my business.

We hosted our work group’s holiday party at the Speakeasy tonight.
I can’t say enough good things.
This place is a hidden gem.
So unique and fun.
Beautiful decor, excellent food and drinks, amazing service and ample room for everyone yet feels quaint and cozy.
Dawn made the booking and food order process easy and once I was there I didn’t have to worry about a thing.
They took care of everything.
Book your party here, you won’t regret it.

Parking