Restaurant
Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant offers a delightful escape into vibrant Caribbean flavors right in Brooklyn. With a cozy atmosphere, it’s perfect for lunch or dinner, catering to solo diners and families alike. The menu boasts comfort food staples like jerk chicken and mouthwatering roti, all reasonably priced. Reviews highlight the welcoming staff, especially Isis, who ensure every visit feels special. Accessibility features like a wheelchair-friendly entrance and ample parking make it easy for everyone to enjoy a taste of the Caribbean.
Food & drink
Vibe
Street View
First let me start off by saying that Sally's has an excellent employee in Isis.She was courteous, professional and respectful she really went out of her way to make our stay enjoyable.My mom and I came for dinner.The vibe is calm and cool.Good music also.Dinner was delicious of course and enough to take home as well.We also ordered another dinner to go for my Dad.I saw many people come in from shopping to order take-out.There are vegetarian options and parking to the right of the restaurant in the back.It is wheelchair accessible and kid friendly.This black owned business should be supported. Would definitely go again.
Will not be returning back! Got there no one greeted us maybe because there was a large group in the back dancing.So we decided to sit at the bar because it was the only seats available.Ordered drinks and food drinks came 1st about 30 mins lata which was 9:05 pm our food came in plastic to go containers.The waitress explained that since they were closing soon the cook put them in the containers I asked her what time y’all close she told me 10:30 mind you I checked their website and they close at 11:30.By this time I was upset I opened my container and it was not what I ordered the waitress had the nerve to tell me I did.I pointed on the menu what I wanted so how you got that mixed up I don’t know.I said my food comes with cabbage where is it and I ordered a side of plantains she’s like ok I’ll go get it and the plantains I’ll take off of your bill which was like 6 or 7 dollars.Another waitress saw the look on my face and said she will give us a drink on the house.After all if that a lady who came in after us and got her food after us which was tacos and cod fish fritters got her food on a plate.Make it make sense!!! I will not be returning at all.
I got excited when I saw that Sally’s was finally open.They actually opened 3 months ago according to the staff.I came on a rainy Tuesday and it was empty.I ordered takeout (prices are high) Jerk chicken, Rice peas, steamed vegetables.$15.24 for a very small plate.There was very little rice and the meat was mostly bones.The jerk/ bbq sauce had a weird taste.What little meat there was, was dry.The food was nasty! Definitely don’t taste like the original Sally’s!
Owner response
Thank you for the feedback.I’m very sorry that your experience with us was not good.Please stop in so we can make it up to you. We are the Original Sally’s and we take all our customers concerns seriously.
Caribbean restaurant
1364 Granville Payne Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11239, United States
Italian restaurant
505 Gateway Dr, Brooklyn, NY 11239, United States