Papa Johns Pizza

This store singlehandedly redeemed the entire Papa Johns chain for me. I have eaten from many different Papa Johns stores all over the map, and it has always left much to be desired.
Whether it was the skimpy toppings, the not-so-stuffed stuffed crust, or even chewy/tough dough, for some reason something has always gone wrong for me with the Papa. But this store changed all that for me.
I did takeout Buy One Get One stuffed crust pizzas, and a side of Oreo bites.
One of the best meals I've had from a pizza chain in general, and for a really good deal. Dough was cooked to perfection and the amount of toppings was ideal.
Extra here means extra.
And stuffed crust means STUFFED crust.
That crust was filled all the way through.
The Oreo bites with the cream cheese icing was a perfect way to top off the meal.
Paired them with a glass of milk, was absolutely delightful. 100% would recommend, even with it being in a ghetto part of town.

Exceptional! The process was quick, and my order was ready exactly when they said it would be.
The staff was friendly, and the pizza was hot and delicious, with the crust perfectly balanced and the toppings generous.
Papa John's in Lake City has definitely mastered the art of providing a speedy and enjoyable pizza pickup experience, making it my preferred choice for a tasty and convenient meal.
Kudos to the team for their efficiency and great service!

The quality was great, food was tasty, but there was only 1 person working due to someone else calling out.
We ordered 2 pizzas on thin crust and 1 NY style.
We totally messed up by not checking before we left to make sure it was correct, so when we got home, we found that the 2 thin crusts were on regular crusts.
Not the end of the world! What we did get was still well made, and we ate it.
Mostly felt bad for the poor guy who was overwhelmed with football Sunday pizza orders.
So I guess my review is that they need to hire more staff...
but we'll still be going here for our pizzas.