Mama Carolla's

Name: Mama Carolla's
Address: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46220, US
Telephone: (317) 259-9412
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.70

Italian restaurant, Family restaurant, Fine dining restaurant

Location: 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States
Phone: (317) 259-9412
Price: $$

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 5-9:30 pm
Wednesday: 5-9:30 pm
Thursday: 5-9:30 pm
Friday: 5-9:30 pm
Saturday: 5-9:30 pm

Food & drink

Vibe

Fried green tomatoes

Chicken parmesan

Tiramisu

Toasted ravioli

Chicken soup

Spaghetti

Rigatoni

Caesar salad

Street View

Menus and Prices

Add Your Review

Reviews

We had a lovely anniversary dinner here last Friday night! I loved the story behind this restaurant and the location is beautiful.
It was a very romantic setting. I ordered the Alfredo with shrimp which was really yummy.
Good thing I’m not a vampire though! 🧛‍♀️ The garlic bread was amazing! 💗 I noticed there was some stuff floating in my lemonade and I think at least one of the “things” was a bug.
🐜 I asked our waiter if I could get a new drink and they brought me a brand new one.
I appreciated that! Good lemonade.
🍋 We ordered the ricotta cake to go and it was delicious! 😋 I’m really glad we picked this restaurant for our Indy weekend trip! 💗

A gorgeous restaurant with family atmosphere and historic vibe. With food that is probably underpriced for the quality and atmosphere, this was well worth the venture and we will definitely be back! A favorite: bruschetta is often hit or miss.
This one is worth it! You must give it a try. An odd addition: orange slices? By the way, it took us months to figure out that you do not have to get a reservation here.
It looks full from online reservations but in fact only some of the seats are reservable and the rest is first come first serve.
Plenty of seats!

Without a doubt, hands down, the BEST meal we’ve ever had in our entire lives.
Our server was an absolute delight and that’s not even to mention the ambience of the establishment.
We ordered, well to be frank, everything!😂 Fried Ravioli, bruschetta, chicken parm, shrimp Alfredo, tiramisu, wine, Moscow mule, and it was all beyond fantastic.
If you’re in Indy even for just one night make this your dinner stop!