4.7 stars based on 2240 ratingsToday's hours: 5-9:30 pmAdd a review
$$ Italian restaurant, Family restaurant, Fine dining restaurant
About
Mama Carolla's stands out as a delightful Italian haven in Indianapolis, situated along the scenic Monon Trail. This women-owned restaurant charms guests with its cozy, historic ambience, making it perfect for a romantic dinner or a family gathering. Offering a range of mouthwatering dishes from crispy fried ravioli to savory chicken parm, the menu balances tradition with creativity. Expect great coffee and dessert offerings too! While free parking can be a bit elusive, the experience is well worth the adventure.
Mama Carolla's is a true gem in Indianapolis! 🌟 The atmosphere is cozy and historic, perfect for a romantic night out. I ordered the shrimp Alfredo, which was scrumptious, and paired it with their fantastic garlic bread!
Don't miss the bruschetta - it's a standout!
Just a heads up, the drinks might have unexpected guests (I found something floating in mine), but the staff was quick to replace it. The ricotta cake was a delightful ending! 🍰 I'll definitely be back for more...✨
