Serafina Italian Restaurant 38th Madison

From the Fridays brunch menu.
Everything was very good, the eggs perfect and the burger seasoned and cooked exactly rare as requested.
One small issue was that I asked for extra gorgonzola but got none.
Still an excellent burger.
Nice place and will return

Owner response

I really enjoyed this particular Serafina Restaurant.
Not all Serafinas are the same! This place had an electric atmosphere, with friendly and accommodating service.
The food is top notch.
I had the Chicken Milanese which was enormous, moist, and delicious.
The fresh arugula and tomatoes gave the meal a nice, overall zest.
Prices were reasonable for Manhattan.
Highly recommend.

Owner response

"Lovely Spot, But the Pasta Missed the Mark" My visit to Serafina on 38th and Madison promised an noon of ambiance and convenience, nestled as it is in the hustle and bustle of Midtown.
It's not every day you find a restaurant that tickles your fancy with its service and setting while letting you pop in quickly thanks to its prime location. Stepping into Serafina, I was instantly taken by the stunning interior—a cozy yet elegant tribute to the charm of Italy.
The warmth of the decor paralleled the staff’s service, attentive and with a genuine smile that made us feel right at home👌 On a chill noon in the city, I was looking forward to a comforting plate of pasta to round off the inviting experience. But then came the food.
It's with a heavy heart I must pen that both pasta dishes we ordered were a letdown 🥲 Italian cuisine, a rich tapestry of flavors, textures, and aromas, is something I've always held in high regard, so my expectations danced on the higher rungs of hope.
However, there was an undeniable disconnect between the allure of the surroundings and the main event itself.
The flavors did not embrace the gusto of Italy; rather, they stumbled, leaving us with a discomfort hard to overlook, and regrettably, unfinished plates. It truly is a shame when the heart of the restaurant—the culinary experience—doesn't sing in harmony with other aspects of dining that were note-perfect.
I appreciate the efforts of the staff and the thought put into the lovely space, but until the recipes are revisited and the pastas pay proper homage to Italian zest, my stars remain a middling three. In food as in life, balance is key, and I hope Serafina finds its footing to match the taste with its service and beauty.
Here’s to hoping for a better bite next time! 🍝

Owner response