Buon Appetito Restaurant & Bar

First time customer.
Called in at 7 to place and order to be ready at 830.
We ordered a Hawaiian, pepperoni and a cheese that was bogo for ordering a specialty pizza and some garlic knots.
Found it odd you can’t pay more to add pepperoni to the free cheese but whatever so we ordered the pepperoni.
Picked the food up right at 830, the guy at the bar was friendly and full of energy.
The atmosphere was cool.
The food however was awful, it was barely warm and overcooked.
Wish it was good because the place is so close, maybe had it been ordered fresh and ate in, but come on.
I’ve drove from fort Myers’s with a pizza from Tony’s and it was hotter than this was and they are 8 minutes away.
Very very disappointed for New Year’s Eve.
Hopefully others have better experiences.

We have lived here 2 years and decided to finally check this place out.
Glad we did! We ordered calamari, Greek salad, pizza and garlic knots.
All were delicious, the stand outs were the pizza and knots.
The owner sang some songs with the other singer and the owner has a great voice! Was an enjoyable night, I wish they were packed all the time because it’s hard to keep a business open.
We will be back.
Our waiter, Ryan was very attentive and on top of all his tables needs.
Give them a try.

This was an awesome place! The food was delicious! The atmosphere was like old school Italian, with the wise guy feel! Mason our server was awesome and made sure we had everything we needed and was very attentive.
The Italian sausage and peppers and it was the best I've ever had! The sauce was so good I couldn't stop eating.
The owner even came out of the kitchen and sang a few songs! Was great.
We will definitely be back! Thanks for the great time.

Owner response