Maggiano's Little Italy

Name: Maggiano's Little Italy
Address: 3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46240, US
Telephone: (317) 814-0700
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.50

Italian restaurant, Bar, Caterer, Event venue, Family restaurant, Lunch restaurant, Takeout restaurant, Restaurant

Location: 3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States
Located in: The Fashion Mall at Keystone
Phone: (317) 814-0700
Price: $$

Opening hours

Sunday: 11 am-9 pm
Monday: 11 am-10 pm
Tuesday: 11 am-10 pm
Wednesday: 11 am-10 pm
Thursday: 11 am-10 pm
Friday: 11 am-11 pm
Saturday: 11 am-11 pm

Food & drink

Vibe

Chocolate Cake

Chicken parmesan

Tiramisu

Spaghetti

Cheesecake

Rigatoni

Stuffed Mushrooms

By owner

Street View

Menus and Prices

Add Your Review

Reviews

The food was great and comfortable environment.
My biggest complaint was our server.
She was barely around while we were there.
We asked for refills on drinks, and she never brought them.
When she did finally come back, she just handed us the bill and walked off.
We asked for boxes, and after a while of waiting, we just left.
So, minus the server, everything else was good.

Wife and I drove some distance to make this happen, and it was well worth every mile.
We wanted to try as many things as we could (create an experience) since we dont get north to often.
Everything from the food to our server Virgil, made for a great experience.
I had the Salmon Oscar and it was devine.
Best Salmon I have had to date at a restaurant.
My wife had the Rigatoni D and absolutely loved it (I tasted it, and was almost jealous).
The Ricotta Garlic Bread and Calamari would be worth a return trip on their own.
The Dessert Sampler is hands down the best way to go for dessert.
The Butter Cake was my favorite though for sure.
The only dish that seemed underwhelming compared to everything else, was the stuffed mushrooms.
Cold and the stuffing tasted like boxed 'stove top'.
I also absolutely enjoyed the Blackberry Bourbon Sour cocktail (though it was really sweet), next time I may request a Rye substitute to compliment my taste more. We were extremely happy and definitely stuffed.
100% goes in our Top 10 for Indy

Owner response

It is great to hear that you both loved our food so much, Keith, and that our staff ensured that you had a great experience.
Thank you for visiting!

We didn't plan on going to this restaurant at first.
The place we had planned to go to had a very long wait time.
So we chose Maggiano's.
There were eight of us and they were able to sit all of us.
We were celebrating two birthdays and a marriage yesterday.
We chose the family style option because we thought it would provide the best experience for us.
Our server was beyond excellent.
She did a wonderful job and it did not stress her out to deal with all the allergies and food intolerance in my family.
We were pleasantly surprised to find out that the $36.99 per person that we paid covered such a large selection of food, and it was unlimited.
Our server even brought out a plate of the best lemon cookies with a strawberry and candles for each of our birthday girls, but also for our newlyweds.
I will definitely go again anytime I'm in that area of Indianapolis.
Highly, highly recommend this restaurant.
🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

Owner response

Serendipity led you to our doors, and we are thrilled it turned into a celebration of love, life, and culinary delights.
Your impromptu decision to join us for family-style feasting and milestone toasts fills us with joy, Tracey.
Kudos to your server for weaving through the maze of dietary needs with grace.
Here’s to lemon cookies lighting the way for future visits.
Until then, we are raising a fork in your honor—highly appreciated, deeply cherished.