East of Chicago Pizza

Name: East of Chicago Pizza
Address: 205 Commercial Ave SE, New Philadelphia, Ohio, 44663, US
Telephone: (330) 364-0005
Rating: 3.90

Pizza restaurant

Contact Info

Location: 205 Commercial Ave SE, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Phone: (330) 364-0005

Opening hours

Monday: 3-9 pm
Tuesday: 3-9 pm
Wednesday: 3-9 pm
Thursday: 11 am-9 pm
Friday: 11 am-9 pm
Saturday: 11 am-9 pm
Sunday: 11 am-9 pm

Services

Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Comfort food
Quick bite

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating

Toilets

Casual

Groups

Credit cards
Debit cards
Credit cards

Good for kids
High chairs

Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Dogs allowed outside

Food & drink

Vibe

Street View

Menus and Prices

Menu 1

Menu 2

Add Your Review

Reviews

Good food and the delivery guy is always really good and nice.
They don't take very long at all either, always have good luck with them.
The one time we gave the delivery guy a good tip because when he delivered a big storm came through and it was very nasty out.
This guy was a good sport about it and we appreciated him delivering.

Normally, we visit the berlin location when we are in town but decided to stop at this location as we were on our way home.
Had 2 subs.
One Italian and one chicken bacon ranch.
Both were delicious, hot, and well made.
Not very pricey either.

They make you pay for the buffet up front so you can't leave from the bad service. Genuinely the worst place to eat in New Philadelphia, no, Tuscarawas, no, northeast Ohio. They claim there is a buffet, but we came here at 5 and there was already a few families here and two pizzas out.
Two parties of 8 came in after us and a couple more couples. They actually just ran out of those two pizzas and would put out one pizza every 10-15 minutes and let the hungry customers fight like animals over what scraps their god East of Chicago allowed them to have. Eventually they ran out of paper plates and that was just when we decided to leave, since I wasn't going to put my air pizza on my air plate to eat. Gross facilities that are unkept, no paper towels or soap in the bathroom, flies in the dining room, and chairs propping doors open and strewn about. Don't go here, go somewhere else.
You deserve better, man.