Andrew’s Diner

It was my first time coming here, and I was pleasantly surprised.
The pancakes were delicious.
The chicken parmesan was so good.
I had ordered a salad and it was ok.

In my opinion, this is one of the best diners you'll come across on the island.
Food is served quickly and prepared well.
I have never had an issue with any of the 35 dishes I tried thus far.
My kids love it here and always , ask to eat at Andrews Diner.
The menu is highly accommodating, no matter what you are looking for.
The atmosphere is comfortable and enjoyable.
The diner is divided into two sections.
The left side seems to be the more fancy side, as the right side is all booths.
Most of the staff have been there for a while.
They seem to be very proficient in taking orders accurately and staying on top of things.
As for the prices they are a bit on the expensive side but you do get what you pay for.
Overall I would recommend this eatery to all.

I’m a long time patron and always support Andrews diner but had a really bad experience tonight. My wife ordered the pork chop meal.
The pork chops were bad.
The meat was inedible and undercooked.
The meat smelled and tasted bad.
The waitress made it seem like they were doing us a favor by taking them back and removing the pork chops from the bill.
We never even mentioned removing the pork chops from the bill but after the waitress spoke to the owner and returned It was made clear that the side dishes would have be paid for and the chops removed from the bill. I felt that was fair until The bill came and the salad, potato and vegetable added up to almost as much as the dinner special so basically they charged almost full boat but without actually providing the full meal as there was no meat. To add, I ordered a cheeseburger which came out from the kitchen after the pork chop debacle and after the table of four next to us were served their meals although they sat a good 15 minutes after we did. The owner was made aware of the situation by his staff and acknowledged to the waitress and hostess that he knew us and that we were regulars but never approached the table or tried to make a reasonable accommodation or explanation.
It seemed as if he was ignoring us so I relayed my disappointment to the hostess.
I told her the entire experience was handled poorly and since the owner stood within ear shot but did not have the decency to come speak to me I would not be returning. He never even said a word to me, He literally ignored us. I feel bad having to write Andrew’s off as our go to but I’ve seen the handwriting on the wall for some time.
This was an insult and I feel terrible about this but this was the owners doing since I tried to reason with the waitress and the hostess.
The hostess, I don’t remember her name but she’s been there for years and years is one of the best around and will be missed.